Technology House, Stratfield Park, Waterlooville, PO7 7XN 023 9223 3611

Highway drainage: cleansed on a cycle, failing on a condition

TL;DR. Highway drainage is cleansed on a cycle, but it fails on a condition, and the two have nothing to do with each other. Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 puts the authority under a duty to maintain. Section 100 gives it the power to scour, cleanse and keep open drains. Section 58 gives it a defence, and that defence turns on what the authority knew and what care it took. A cyclic schedule is a plan. A level record shows the condition between visits.

Key takeaways

  • Section 41 places the highway authority under a duty to maintain a highway maintainable at the public expense.
  • Section 100 lets the authority construct drains and scour, cleanse and keep open all drains situated in the highway or adjoining land.
  • Section 100 defines a drain to include a ditch, gutter, watercourse, soak-away, bridge, culvert, tunnel and pipe.
  • The section 58 defence requires proof that the authority took such care as was reasonably required to secure that the highway was not dangerous for traffic.
  • The court must consider whether the authority knew, or could reasonably have been expected to know, that the condition was likely to cause danger.
  • Cyclic cleansing tells you when a gully was last visited. It does not tell you what state it is in today.

Table of Contents

On this page

Last updated: 31 August 2026

What does the law require of highway drainage?

A duty to maintain, and a power to keep the highway drainage clear. Section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 states that the authority who are for the time being the highway authority for a highway maintainable at the public expense are under a duty, subject to subsections (2) and (4), to maintain the highway.

Highway drainage is cleansed on a cycle but fails on a condition, and the section 58 defence turns on what the authority knew.
Cleansed on a cycle. Fails on a condition.

The highway drainage powers sit in section 100. The authority may construct or lay such drains as they consider necessary, erect barriers to divert surface water into or through an existing drain, and scour, cleanse and keep open all drains situated in the highway or in such land. The section defines a drain broadly, to include a ditch, gutter, watercourse, soak-away, bridge, culvert, tunnel and pipe.

That definition matters more than it looks. It means highway drainage is not a gully-shaped problem. It is a network of very different asset types, most of them buried, some of them on adjoining land, all of them subject to the same duty and none of them instrumented by default.

Why does the section 58 defence change the calculation?

Because it is a defence about knowledge, not about schedules, and highway drainage is where the two diverge most. Section 58 allows an authority to prove that it had taken such care as in all the circumstances was reasonably required to secure that the part of the highway to which the action relates was not dangerous for traffic.

The court must have particular regard to a list, and one item on it is decisive for drainage. The court considers whether the authority knew, or could reasonably have been expected to know, that the condition of the part of the highway was likely to cause danger to users. The other matters include the character of the highway and the traffic reasonably expected to use it, the standard of maintenance appropriate for that kind of highway, the state of repair a reasonable person would expect, and what warning notices were displayed where a repair could not reasonably be made in time.

The section 58 defence checklist showing that the court considers what the highway authority knew or could reasonably have been expected to know.
The defence is about knowledge. A schedule is not knowledge.

There is also a limitation worth knowing. The defence does not succeed merely by proving that a competent person was engaged to carry out maintenance, unless it is also shown that the authority gave proper instructions and that the contractor carried them out.

Read those together and the practical highway drainage question sharpens. Could you reasonably have been expected to know that this gully was silted before the water came over the kerb? If the only record is a cleansing date, the honest answer is that you knew when it was last emptied and nothing about what happened since.

Why does cyclic cleansing miss the failure?

Because highway drainage silts unevenly and the cycle is even. Two gullies cleansed on the same day, on the same round, will be in completely different states nine months later, because one sits under trees on a slope by a construction access and the other does not.

  1. Leaf fall concentrates in a few weeks and blocks the grating rather than the pot.
  2. Construction traffic drags silt onto a stretch of road for a season and then stops.
  3. A soak-away loses infiltration gradually and never announces it.
  4. A gully connection collapses, so the pot empties normally and the outlet does not.
  5. An outfall ditch on adjoining land grows in, and the whole run backs up from the far end.

None of those highway drainage failures is visible from a cleansing schedule, and the first two are seasonal, which means an annual cycle will hit them at the wrong time as often as the right one. The asset that floods is rarely the asset that was overdue.

Cross-section of a road gully silting up so the pot fills and the outlet restricts between scheduled cleansing visits.
The pot fills, the outlet restricts, and the schedule says next March.

What does monitoring highway drainage actually measure?

Standing water in the highway drainage where there should be none, and how long it takes to clear. A healthy gully pot holds its designed water seal and returns to it quickly after rain. A silted or restricted one holds a higher level, drains more slowly, and eventually stops drawing down between events at all.

AQUAIOT Radar suits the application because it never touches the water. It is 60 GHz non-contact level sensing accurate to within ±2 mm, reading through foam, vapour and condensation, with ATEX variants where a chamber requires them. In a gully, a catchpit, a soak-away or an outfall chamber there is nothing submerged to silt up, which matters on an asset whose entire failure mode is silt.

Across a wider highway drainage network, AQUAIOT’s sewer monitoring service applies the same sensing to manholes, chambers and outfalls, reporting over encrypted cellular and LoRaWAN into the AQUAIOT Cloud with threshold alarms, trendlines and exports, plus open APIs into a highway asset management system.

Moving from cyclic gully cleansing to condition-based highway drainage maintenance using continuous level data.
Cleanse the ones that need it, when they need it.

The realistic highway drainage deployment is not every gully. It is the ones with a history: the stretch that floods, the dip that ponds, the outfall that backs up, the chamber that appears in every complaint. Instrument twenty of those and you have converted the worst part of the network from cyclic to condition-based without touching the rest of the programme.

What changes operationally?

Three things change in highway drainage, in rough order of value. The tanker goes where the silt is rather than where the round says. A rising baseline becomes a work order weeks before the flood rather than a callout after it. And the authority gets a dated record of the condition of specific assets between visits, and of when it responded.

It is worth being precise about that last one rather than overselling what highway drainage data does. Monitoring does not create a defence and no sensor discharges a statutory duty. What it does is show the condition of each monitored asset between visits, so the response can come before the flood.

Frequently asked questions

Who is responsible for highway drainage?

The highway authority, under the section 41 duty to maintain a highway maintainable at the public expense, with drainage powers under section 100. Those powers extend to drains in land adjoining or lying near the highway, not only within the carriageway, and section 100 also requires the authority to pay compensation to an owner or occupier who suffers damage from the exercise of the powers.

What counts as a drain under the Highways Act?

More than a pipe. Section 100 defines a drain as including a ditch, gutter, watercourse, soak-away, bridge, culvert, tunnel and pipe. For a highway drainage monitoring programme that is useful, because it makes clear the duty covers the open ditch at the end of the run as much as the gully at the kerb.

Does a cleansing schedule satisfy the section 58 defence?

It is evidence, and it is relevant to the standard of maintenance appropriate for that kind of highway, which is one of the matters the court considers. But section 58 also asks whether the authority knew or could reasonably have been expected to know that the condition was likely to cause danger, and a schedule speaks to activity rather than condition. The two are not the same question.

Can you monitor a gully without a confined space entry?

Yes, and that is much of the point. Non-contact radar reads the level from above the water, so installation is a lid-off fitting rather than an entry, and there is no submerged element to foul or retrieve. The reading then arrives at a desk instead of being fetched.

AQUAIOT call to action for highway drainage level monitoring on gullies, catchpits and outfalls.
Instrument the stretch that floods, not the whole network.

The narrow version

Nobody is going to instrument a county’s worth of highway drainage, and nothing in the Highways Act suggests they should. The argument is narrower and easier to fund: on the handful of highway drainage locations that flood repeatedly, a cleansing date says nothing about the condition since the last visit, and a level trace shows it.

Both cost less than the flood. Speak to an AQUAIOT engineer about levelling the gullies and outfall chambers on the stretches that keep coming back.

By GP, Digital and IoT lead at AQUAIOT.

Previous Post
Newer Post
Shopping Cart (0 items)